FAA and NTSB Tensions Rise Over Deadly Mid-Air Collision Probe
A highly public investigation into a fatal mid-air collision near Reagan National Airport has exposed growing tensions between the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) and the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). The crash, which killed 67 people in January 2025, involved a military Black Hawk helicopter and a PSA Airlines as American Eagle Flight 5342, and has sparked accusations of mismanagement, stonewalling, and safety oversight failures.
During three days of hearings, NTSB Chair Jennifer Homendy led a sharp critique of the FAA, accusing the agency of obstructing the investigation by withholding key documents and creating a culture where air traffic controllers were discouraged from reporting safety concerns. The hearings revealed that controllers had previously flagged Route 4, a helicopter path that intersected with aircraft descent paths, as dangerous. FAA officials were reportedly warned about the risks but delayed action, calling it “too political” to revise the route.
At the time of the crash, the Black Hawk helicopter was flying 78 feet above its authorized ceiling. Investigators also revealed that the helicopter’s altimeter readings were inaccurate by about 100 feet, and pilots were using night vision goggles, which may have limited visibility. Despite these concerns being raised in internal meetings, FAA management allegedly failed to act decisively.
NTSB board members accused the FAA of reassigning or silencing staff who raised safety issues, further eroding trust between the agencies. FAA representatives defended their actions, claiming they supported the investigation and were actively addressing safety concerns.
The hearings highlighted deep-rooted issues within the aviation oversight system. While the NTSB makes safety recommendations, it is the FAA that enforces them. Aviation experts noted that this case illustrates systemic inertia and the need for reform in FAA personnel policies and funding structures.
The crash, the first fatal accident involving a major U.S. airline in over 15 years, occurred just outside Washington, D.C., putting additional political pressure on both agencies. Safety experts believe the NTSB is leveraging the high-profile nature of the incident to push for major reforms in airspace management and interagency cooperation.
Despite the friction, experts emphasize that collaboration between technical teams at both agencies continues. However, the public airing of disagreements has fueled questions about transparency, accountability, and the state of aviation safety in the U.S.
Related News: https://airguide.info/?s=NTSB, https://airguide.info/?s=FAA, https://airguide.info/?s=Reagan+National
Sources: AirGuide Business airguide.info, bing.com, nytimes.com, abcnews.go.com